MoMento 6: Cinematic. Roberta Thornley, James K. Lowe, and Greta Anderson

MoMento 6: Cinematic. Roberta Thornley, James K. Lowe, and Greta Anderson

0.00 20.00


MoMento 6: Cinematic. Roberta Thornley, James K. Lowe, and Greta Anderson

Published by PhotoForum September, 2010

Editor: Amanda A’Hara

Design: Amanda A’Hara

Text: Serena Bentley

View as PDF

Add To Cart


Photography has a complex relationship with the moving image.

Unlike cinema, the photograph functions as a fragment lifted

from a continuum. Accordingly, each element a photograph

contains hints at a narrative that is ultimately – inevitably -

unresolved. Rejecting the ‘snapshot’ in favour of work that is

meticulously staged, Greta Anderson, James K. Lowe and Roberta

Thornley embrace the tension between photograph and film still,

operating in a grey area where stories are built in single frames.

And built is a key term here, for the photographs in this issue are

carefully conceived and fabricated. Take James K. Lowe for instance,

who describes himself as a maker, not taker, of images. Riffing on

the work of Gregory Crewdson and Philip-Lorca diCorcia, Lowe

sets his scenes within the urban landscape. These environments

serve as stage sets upon which intense psychodramas unfold.

Lowe keenly examines the intricacies of human interaction and

emotion; his figures often appear lost in thought. This is the case

with the female character who carries a small boy in Home (2010).

Nuzzled in the safety of his bearer’s neck, the child’s gaze meets

our own, his stare amplified by the retro boy painting propped

up on the deck behind him. It is this exchange that captivates

the viewer and implicates us in Lowe’s mysterious narrative.

For Greta Anderson, it is not human exchanges, but the surroundings

in which her figures appear that are important. Often her subjects

complement (or even compete with) the environments they

occupy. In Film Stills – Part-time (1998) a woman clad in a white

swimsuit crouches beneath a waterfall, her pale skin enlivened by

the white spray of water falling behind her. In Film Stills – Part-time

2 (1998), a shirtless man hovers above speckled paving interrupted

by a curious protrusion of conifer. Nature always seems to find a

way in. Anderson’s landscapes are key to our understanding of the

images. Rather than simply providing a backdrop, these exquisite

surroundings have a force of their own. Witness Film Stills – Hood’s

(2009), shrubby tree. Reaching skywards, its shadow creeps like

gnarled fingers across the yard. Sometimes the photographer gives

the environment free reign by physically containing her subjects.

Film Stills – Part-time 3, (1998), presents a figure enclosed in an

inflatable pool. Pushed to the side of the frame and consumed by

his aqua cell, our attention is instead drawn to a common garden

shrub, spot-lit in vibrant yellow while Auckland’s sky tower beckons

beacon-like in the distance.

In this way, inanimate objects contribute directly to a photograph’s

mise-en-scène. Roberta Thornley amplifies their significance by

omitting human figures completely. In Float (2010)  and Couple

(2009) , Thornley focuses on the everyday. Toying with the uncanny,

she re-presents the immediately familiar as unusual or strange.

Essentially mundane items like plastic chairs and inflatable kiddies’

pools emerge from murky suburban backgrounds. Unfettered by

human imposition, the objects are anthropomorphized, lit by a dull

glow. The stillness of each frame enables the sculptural quality of the

objects to shine through. In Couple curious stacks of chairs, almost

tipping in on themselves reflect in their shape a visual relationship

with the curving banana fronds that grow behind them. Slowly,

Thornley’s sophisticated compositions reveal themselves. Even in

peopled scenes the objects Thornley selects retain their power. A

lurid red fly-swat (in Forest 2008 ) and flaccid netting (in Net 2007 )

operate as clues that hint at a wider narrative.

The artists featured here reveal the power of the photo-story.

Unlike cinema, their work is not confined by a set duration. As

viewers, we have the ability to explore these photographs at our

own pace, and in doing so, actively participate in the construction

of meaning.

Serena Bentley